The New Diligence
Menu

Blog


Living Inside a Bubble: A Behavioral Field Guide for Today’s Investor

11/11/2025

0 Comments

 
Picture
Something unusual is happening in markets right now. Trillion-dollar companies are spending like startups, and both Wall Street and Main Street are reaping the rewards.

The numbers tell a remarkable story. Nvidia commits $100 billion to OpenAI. OpenAI signs a $300 billion deal with Oracle. Oracle spends billions on Nvidia chips. It's a circular carousel of capital expenditures that would make any financial historian smile and squint at the same time.

The tech giants have essentially said: "We're all in this together. If one of us is going to spend absurdly, we're all going to spend absurdly."

And yet, unlike the dot-com bubble where companies were burning cash with no profits in sight, or the housing bubble built on the fantasy that real estate prices only go up, this time the foundation looks different. 

These companies are printing money. Apple, Microsoft, Google, Amazon, Meta all have profit margins that would make Big Oil blush. The AI infrastructure boom is real, the technology is transformative, and the capital expenditures are being funded by actual cash flow, not debt-fueled speculation¹.

So here's the dilemma: does this “bubble” end in tears, or does it build the railroad tracks of the 21st century? Are we in 1996 or 1999? Early innings or the ninth?

No one knows. Not you, not me, not the loudest voices on X/twitter or YouTube with the “macro threads” or hours-long videos.

But here's what we can know: how you're thinking about this moment, what it's doing to your decision-making, and whether your behavior is aligned with your actual risk tolerance or just your current emotional state.

This isn't an article about where the market is going. It's an article about where you are (psychologically, emotionally, and behaviorally) while we’re living inside a moment of heightened uncertainty and elevated valuations.

Who Are You When the Market Makes You Look Smart?

Let's start with an uncomfortable question: Are you acting like the investor you think you are, or the one the market’s rewarding right now?

You've probably spent years thinking of yourself as a disciplined investor. You've read the articles, internalized the lessons, nodded along to the wisdom of staying rational. You know about P/E ratios and you understand that valuations matter. You've probably even lectured someone about the dangers of chasing performance.

But lately… you check your online dashboard more often, mesmerized by your account values. You’ve been talking a little more confidently about the future of AI and its applications. Maybe you’ve even said, “This time is different.”

There's a cognitive dissonance here that's worth examining. Your self-concept as a "smart, disciplined investor" is doing battle with your brokerage statement. And right now, your brokerage statement is probably winning.

This is what behavioral economists call the bubble paradox: being sophisticated enough to recognize you might be in a bubble, but human enough to participate anyway ². The awareness doesn't protect you; it just makes you a little more uneasy while you do the same thing everyone else is doing.

Every mania comes with its own story:

1999: "The internet changes everything. This is a paradigm shift. Traditional valuation metrics don't apply to these growth companies."
2006: "Real estate always goes up over the long term. They're not making any more land. This time is different because of global demand and low interest rates."
2025: "AI is genuinely transformative technology, and unlike the dot-com bubble, these companies have massive profits and cash flows. The capex spending is building real infrastructure. This isn't speculation, it's strategic investment!"

What’s funny is that all three narratives contain truth.

The internet did change everything.
Real estate has been a good long-term bet.
And AI is and will be transformative.
​
The question isn't whether the narrative is true. The question is: what does this truth mean for you?

What Your Portfolio Says About You

One of the most useful things you can do right now is honestly assess where you are in this market environment, not where you think you should be.
​
Your current allocation tells a story, not about returns, but about your fears.

If you're 100% in technology stocks:
You’re not primarily afraid of losing money, you’re afraid of missing out. You don’t want to be sitting in Treasuries at 4–5% while your friends, colleagues, and your brother-in-law at Thanksgiving ride AI higher. You’d rather risk a 40% drawdown with the crowd than underperform alone. That’s not a criticism; it’s an observation about revealed preferences. The pain you’re avoiding is exclusion.

Edge: You may end up on the right side of the trade. The narrative behind technology and artificial intelligence might genuinely be different enough, and these companies might be strong enough, that elevated valuations are consistently justified.

Risk: You can drift into insulating yourself from contradictory evidence out of fear of being left behind.
 
If you've moved heavily to cash or short-term bonds:
You're not primarily afraid of missing out, you're afraid of being the sucker. Your nightmare scenario isn't missing gains; it’s a 30–40% drawdown you “should have” seen coming. You'd rather preserve capital and feel smart than risk looking foolish for staying invested through a large drawdown. You're optimizing for the ability to say "I knew it" rather than for total return.
​
Edge: You’re grounded and not chasing trends.

Risk: Skepticism can quickly harden into cynicism, and you can miss a significant compounding opportunity.
 Being underexposed out of principle can quietly turn into its own kind of bubble, a bubble of disbelief. Keep your skepticism flexible enough to adapt when reality shifts.

If you're somewhere in between, paralyzed and afraid of what to do next:
You're afraid of both. You haven’t added to equities for fear of buying the top, and you haven’t trimmed for fear of missing the next leg up. So you're frozen, reading articles like this one, hoping for clarity that never comes.
​
Edge: You are self-aware enough to understand that making long-term investment choices is tough. That's valuable. The moment you lose the ability to question your own positioning is the moment you become vulnerable.

Risk: Decision paralysis. Every month your accounts grow is like validation for doing nothing.

How to minimize portfolio regret

Here's what behavioral economics has taught us about regret: it's asymmetric and social.
  • Asymmetric: Missing out on collective gains often stings more than sharing collective losses ³. “Everyone got hurt” is easier to bear than “I sat in cash while everyone doubled.”
  • Social: We care (a lot) about relative performance versus our peer group, not just absolute returns ⁴.

This is why the bubble concept is so psychologically powerful. It's not just about greed; it's about the unbearable social pain of being left out while everyone around you participates in a collective gain.

Now, ask yourself this: Given what you know about yourself, about which flavor of regret you try to avoid, is your current portfolio aligned with minimizing that regret?

If your deepest fear is missing out, but you're sitting in cash trying to "be disciplined," you're building future regret. When tech goes up another 30%, you won't feel disciplined, you’ll feel the sting of regret.

If your deepest fear is losing money you already have, but you're staying fully invested because everyone says "you can't time the market," you're also building future regret. When the next 30% correction comes, you won't feel patient. You'll feel reckless.

The goal is to build a portfolio you can live with through whatever comes next, a portfolio aligned with your actual psychology, not your aspirational self-image.

Building A Sound Plan For Any Outcome

Everyone says to "have a plan" and stick to it. But plans fail not because they're bad plans, but because they ignore how we feel when we are emotionally vulnerable.

So let's talk about building a different kind of plan, one that works with your psychology instead of pretending you're a perfectly rational decision-making machine.

1. The Mechanical Rebalance
Automate it. Set calendar reminders. Use technology to rebalance back to your target allocation. Not based on market conditions. Not based on how you feel. Based on the calendar.

Your tech sector allocation drifted from 40% to 65% because tech outperformed? Sell enough to get back to 40%. Your bonds are now 15% instead of 25%? Buy more bonds.

The beauty of this approach: it removes the decision from the moment. You're not trying to time anything. You're just maintaining your chosen risk exposure. It's mechanical, boring, and it works in accordance with risk tolerance.

2. The Buddy System
Having an outside party perspective is never a bad idea. Partner with another investor or an advisor, ideally someone with similar values but different emotional triggers than you.

Not to judge. Not to issue orders. Just to observe: "Hey, I notice you're sounding really certain about this right now. Just wanted to flag that for you."

The psychological benefit: it's nearly impossible to see your own emotional state clearly in the moment. You need an outside observer.

3. The Regret Minimizer
Write down which regret you'd rather live with:

"I sold too early and missed the last 30% of gains"
OR
"I rode it down 40% from the top"

Then, before every significant portfolio decision, read this. You're not predicting what the market will do. You're choosing which regret you're willing to bear.

The psychological benefit: it transforms vague anxiety into explicit choice. You're not avoiding regret (that’s impossible). You're choosing which regret you can live with.

4. The Permission Letter
Write a letter to yourself, right now, giving future-you permission to:
  • Sell even when it's still going up
  • Miss out on gains if you've met your financial goals
  • Look "wrong" in the short term
  • Ignore what your friends/colleagues/family are doing
  • Feel the discomfort of being out of step with consensus

Date it. Sign it. Save it somewhere you'll see it when you're paralyzed by a decision.
The psychological benefit: in moments of decision paralysis, what we often need isn't more information. We need permission. This gives you permission from the one person whose approval you actually need: yourself.
 
None of these tools will help you predict when a bubble pops, or if it pops at all. That's not the point. The point is to create a system aligned with your risk tolerance and psychology so you’re not whipsawed by the last three months of market action.

This Might Not Be the Top (And That's Okay)

Let's be clear about something: I'm not predicting a crash. I don't know if we're in the fifth inning or the ninth inning of this innovation and capex boom. Nobody does.

History says bubbles destroy capital but leave infrastructure. The railroads of the 1840s. The fiber optics of the 1990s ⁵. Maybe AI is next.

Maybe the hundreds of billions being spent on data centers and GPUs is more than we need right now. Maybe some of these companies are overpaying for compute capacity that will sit partially idle. Maybe the returns on all this capex spending will disappoint in the near term.
Or maybe… that “excess” builds the rails for applications we can’t imagine yet.

There’s also a plausible path where this so-called bubble doesn’t burst, it just compresses. Returns run 4% instead of 20% for a few years as earnings grow into valuations. Not exciting, not catastrophic.

Or yes, we could get a good ole 40-50% drawdown that feels like the world is ending and then, eventually, becomes just another historical footnote.

I don't know which scenario plays out, but you don't need to predict the ending to manage your behavior during the middle.

The investors who navigate cycles successfully aren’t the ones who called the turn. They’re the ones who built portfolios aligned with their values and risk tolerance, installed guardrails against emotional decisions, and stuck with it through the noise.


It doesn't make for good cocktail party conversation. You can't brag about it on social media. But it works.
​


​

More Reading:
The Myth of the Perfect Age for Financial Success
The Psychology of Comparison: How Social Media Rewires Our Money Mindset
Mental Accounting: Why the Same Dollar Never Feels the Same
Return to Blog
_____________________________________________________________________
​References:
1. Shiller, R. J. (2000). Irrational Exuberance. Princeton University Press.
2. Barberis, N., Shleifer, A., & Vishny, R. (1998). “A Model of Investor Sentiment.” Journal of Financial Economics.
3.  Bikhchandani, S., Hirshleifer, D., & Welch, I. (1992). “A Theory of Fads and Informational Cascades.” Journal of Political Economy.
4. Thaler, R. H., & Sunstein, C. R. (2009). Nudge. Penguin Books.
5. Odlyzko, A. (2010). “The Collapse of the High-Tech Bubble.” ACM Networker.
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Andrew Lancaster, CFP​​®

    Categories

    All
    Behavioral Finance
    Building Wealth
    Financial Psychology
    Personal Finance
    Saving Strategies
    Spending Wisely

    RSS Feed

© 2025 The New Diligence
Home
Disclosures
Terms and Conditions
Privacy Policy
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • Disclosures
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • Disclosures